Project LITT homepage Information about Project LITT Software Profiles Software Lists Software Search
 
Information about Project LITT

Project Focus

Characteristics of "Talking Storybook" Programs

Classroom Research

Contacting Project LITT
     
Project Focus

Project LITT focuses on the roles that technology can play in improving the reading skills of students with learning disabilities. Research efforts center around one type of reading software: hypermedia-based children's literature programs, sometimes called "talking storybooks."

Talking storybooks are one of the most common types of reading programs. Among the most familiar are series such as Living Books (e.g., Just Grandma and Me), Discis Books, and WiggleWorks. These programs read stories aloud to students in realistic digitized speech, colorful graphics accompany the text, and students can often interact with both the text and graphics in the stories.

The questions under study in Project LITT concern the effectiveness of this type of software for students with learning disabilities. Talking storybook programs offer many potential advantages: they are interesting and motivating, they are often highly interactive and engage students' attention, and they support the reading process by reading text aloud. However, the motivational features of the programs may distract students with learning disabilities from the reading task. It is unclear whether these programs are beneficial for this group of learners.

Top
     
Characteristics of "Talking Storybook" Programs

The first step in the study of the effectiveness of hypermedia-based children's literature programs was to identify and describe the characteristics of all existing programs.

Of interest in this project were CD-ROM-based programs offering interactive versions of children's literature. Excluded were programs with no text, those that did not offer speech, and those with nonfiction text (e.g., science and social studies programs). Also excluded were programs with estimated readability levels of grade 9 and above.

In 1996-97, a nationwide search was conducted to locate programs, and more than 300 talking storybooks were found. The programs were reviewed and evaluated by Project LITT staff to determine the characteristics of this body of software. (Descriptions of the programs can be found in the Software Profiles section of this web site.)

Several conclusions can be drawn from this study:

  • There is a large number of talking storybook programs available, and this body of software is quite heterogeneous.

  • Programs differ in the types of stories they offer, the length and difficulty levels of text, the degree to which there are opportunities for interactions with text and graphics, and the types of activities included in the program in addition to the stories.

  • Several programs offer versions of stories in languages other than English; Spanish versions are the most common.

  • Print books accompany some programs; however, the text and illustrations in the software may differ from those in the book.

  • The readability levels of text in talking storybook programs may not be consistent with the age or grade levels recommended by the publisher.

  • Although programs read the text on the "page" aloud to students, some do not allow students to ask to hear individual words read aloud.

  • There is wide variation among programs in opportunities for interaction with graphics. In some programs, there are no opportunities; in others, there are dozens on each page.

  • Some programs include features and activities which support the reading process; examples are glossaries, writing activities, and lessons on reading skills such as decoding and comprehension.

  • Some programs contain games and other activities that are not related to reading.

The next step in the study of this body of software was consultation with students with learning disabilities and their teachers. Focus groups of teachers and students were asked to provide information about the age-appropriateness of programs and their instructional strengths and weaknesses.

Students were enthusiastic about the programs and thought they would be fun to use. While students liked the interactivity of the software, teachers favored programs that emphasized interactions with text rather than interactions with graphics. Teachers preferred programs that offered features such as writing activities. In general, teachers felt that talking storybook programs were most appropriate for elementary grade students.

Top
     
Classroom Research

The next studies in Project LITT focused on the instructional value of talking storybook programs for students with learning disabilities. All were conducted in classroom settings.

Two exploratory studies took place in 1997-98. First, naturalistic methods were used to gather information about the strategies students with learning disabilities use when they interact with talking storybook programs. Students were observed and videotaped as they interacted with programs under unstructured conditions. In general, students chose to access those portions of the programs that did not require reading. Students spent much of their time interacting with hot spots in the graphics, engaging in activities in the programs, and playing games; little time was spent interacting with the text. Reading gains were minimal.

In the second exploratory study of 1997-98, different levels of instructional support were provided to students to determine the types of interventions needed to maximize reading gains. Two levels of instructional support were studied: moderate and more intense. In the moderate condition, students were asked to read aloud the text on each "page" of the talking storybook program. In the more intense condition, students read that text aloud until their performance met a minimum criterion for accuracy. As instructional support increased, students' gains in reading recognition skills also increased.

In 1998-99, a large-scale investigation will be conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of talking storybooks in improving reading skills. In addition, a case study approach will be used to evaluate the effectiveness of bilingual versions of this software for bilingual students with learning disabilities.

Top
     
Contacting Project LITT
Mailing address:
Project LITT
San Diego State University
6505 Alvarado Road, Suite 204
San Diego, CA 92120-1878
Phone:
(619) 594-8591
E-mail:
Rena Lewis, Ph.D., Project Director, rlewis@mail.sdsu.edu

Top

 

Project LITT Homepage | Information about Project LITT | Software Profiles | Software Lists | Software Search

This web page was developed by Project LITT staff at San Diego State University under a grant from the Department of Education. It does not represent the opinions of San Diego State University. Also, its contents do not necessarily represent the policy of the Department of Education, and you should not assume endorsement by the federal government.

 

  All web pages, database, graphics, and content copyright © 1998, Project LITT. Design and coding by Corey Fayman
last updated 9/26/98